Friday, January 1, 2016

Operation Arcana, edited by John Joseph Adams

Find this book
(Military Fantasy) These sixteen entertaining stories explore the role of warfare in fantasy, with everything from marines fighting trolls, to goblins fighting each other, to angels flying airplanes. (114,007 words; Time: 6h:20m)

Rating: ★★★★☆ 4 RSR-recommended stories + 3 others out of 16

"Operation Arcana," edited by John Joseph Adams, published on by .

A Magical Anthology Worth Fighting For

Combat has turned up in high fantasy at least since the Battle of Pelinnor Fields, and seven of the sixteen stories here are drawn from that tradition. Stories that asked "what if the allies in WWII had had magic?" have been around at least since Captain America fought Hitler, and seven of these stories come from that tradition. The steampunk story involves a more nineteenth-century type of warfare, while the Neverland story is in a class by itself.

What almost all of these stories have in common is that they're uncommonly good. While we only recommended four stories as having the quality and sophistication we expect for potential Hugo Nominees, eleven more are still fun reads. By comparison, from a random set of 16 stories, we'd recommend only 2 or 3, we'd recommend against 6, and half of the remaining 7 or 8 would be "okay, but not much fun."

This anthology rocks.

Specific Recommendations

Although we didn't give five stars to any story, we found four that were worth four stars. These stories do not, in general, pack a heavy emotional punch; don't expect to cry at the end.

Bone Eaters, by Glen Cook
"The Company," an army with magical and ordinary weapons, marches toward an eventual conflict with "The Lady," a powerful, evil witch, but she does things to delay them and to try to gain control of them. This story revolves around one of those delays, but it focuses on a young girl, captured when she and friends unwisely tried to rob the Company. She has some power, although she's not trained, and it's possible that she may be of help--or not.

The Damned One Hundred, by Jonathan Maberry
The Red pass is all that stands between the Hakkian army and the people of the West. Kellur is an old, experienced soldier, and he knows his people stand no chance, but there's an old temple next to the Red Gate, where the "Sisters" worship the old gods. Kellur believes they have the power to save his people (even though they hate them) and he's willing to do anything to get their help. Anything.

The Way Home, by Linda Nagata
US Marines are used to war being Hell, but this squad is stuck there for real. Every hour a new demon materializes, and every hour they have to slay it. There are brief opportunities for people to escape, one at a time, but every soldier who escapes leaves the rest of them more vulnerable.

Weapons in the Earth, by Myke Cole
Young Twig and a group of Black-Horn goblins have been captured by the Gibberer's band. Twig's people are cattle farmers, not really fighters, but they have strong magic to help them. Unfortunately, the only sorcerer in Twig's group is senile, and Twig's own power is useless. But he needs to do something. He and his friends will die from the bitter cold if the Gibberer doesn't kill them first.

Other Reviews: Search Web, GoodReads.com


Dynamic Table Features

  • Rate & flag stories with next to each story title. Your ratings carry over to all RSR pages with dynamic tables
  • Navigate big tables with . Click ↻Mobile View if the full size page is hard to read on a small screen or window. Click to minimize/maximize the gray command box.
  • Change table groupings with . Changing the grouping to Publication is useful if you're a magazine subscriber. Grouping New Writer stories by Score could help prioritize your reading.
  • Highlight stories with . An orange highlight occurs if a yellow highlight intersects an existing red highlight.
  • See your ratings with . They're grouped by Category to simplify Hugo, Locus, Nebula, and magazine-specific nominations.
  • Backup your ratings with . Do this regularly, and definitely prior to clearing your browser cache so you can restore your ratings afterwards. It updates the URL with your data, which can be saved in your browser as a date/time stamped bookmark. If your browser replicates bookmarks across platforms, access the bookmark from another device to transfer your ratings. Repeat after you use each device.

No comments (may contain spoilers):

Post a Comment (comment policy)