Sunday, August 5, 2018

Extrasolar, edited by Nick Gevers

[Anthology]
★★★☆☆ Mixed

(Hard SF) This anthology challenges writers to produce stories that explore extrasolar planets and incorporate the things we’ve learned about such things during the past couple of decades. (92,088 words; Time: 5h:06m)


"Extrasolar," edited by Nick Gevers, published on by .

Not Quite as Advertised

From the theme of the anthology (stories that incorporate recent scientific learnings about exoplanets), one would expect stories that make serious use of the science or which at least get the science right. Not necessarily hard-SF stories, but stories where the science matters.

Out of the 14 original stories, only three actually do this (and of those three, I only recommended one). For six of the stories I found so much bad science or outright mysticism that I couldn't suspend disbelief long enough to enjoy the story at all.

However, I did recommend three stories (plus one honorable mention), and that's enough to give the anthology as a whole three stars, even though it's something of a mixed bag overall.

Other Reviews: Search Web, GoodReads.com
Nick Gevers Info: Interviews, Websites, ISFDB

Follow RSR on Twitter, Facebook, RSS, or E-mail.


Dynamic Table Features

  • Rate & flag stories with next to each story title. Your ratings carry over to all RSR pages with dynamic tables
  • Navigate big tables with . Click ↻Mobile View if the full size page is hard to read on a small screen or window. Click to minimize/maximize the gray command box.
  • Change table groupings with . Changing the grouping to Publication is useful if you're a magazine subscriber. Grouping New Writer stories by Score could help prioritize your reading.
  • Highlight stories with . An orange highlight occurs if a yellow highlight intersects an existing red highlight.
  • See your ratings with . They're grouped by Category to simplify Hugo, Locus, Nebula, and magazine-specific nominations.
  • Backup your ratings with . Do this regularly, and definitely prior to clearing your browser cache so you can restore your ratings afterwards. It updates the URL with your data, which can be saved in your browser as a date/time stamped bookmark. If your browser replicates bookmarks across platforms, access the bookmark from another device to transfer your ratings. Repeat after you use each device.

No comments (may contain spoilers):

Post a Comment (comment policy)