News & Highlights

RSR Selections: Diversity in SF/F Short Fiction
🌈LGBT: 45 outstanding stories with LGBT characters (31 free)
📚PoC: 92 outstanding stories by People of Color (62 free)

Monthly & Annual Best SF/F Lists
2018: Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec; 📅Year-To-Date
2017: 🏆Best SF/F Top 30% out of 800 (142 free); ✨High Fantasy 🌈LGBT
2016: 🏆Best SF/F Top 31% out of 885 (161 free); 🚀Hard SF 🌈LGBT 📚PoC
2015: 🏆Best SF/F Top 35% out of 596 (111 free); 🚀Hard SF

August 2018 Ratings

5★ & 4★ Stories: 10; Time & Words: ⌚7h:21m 💬132.4K
Recommended By Stories: → Due next month
Total Stories: 55; Time & Words: ⌚22h 💬412.2K
Read How to Use RSR on the sidebar or this link to use this post.

Rocket Stack Rank at WorldCon 76

We will both attend the 76th World Science Fiction Convention in San Jose this week. For the benefit of fans who want to meet us and chat a bit, here's a part of our schedule.

Stroll With The Stars

Fans meet with a few program participants for a casual walk around the convention center.

This event happens every morning, from Friday August 17 to Monday August 20, at 9:00 AM to 10:00 AM. It always meets in the Lower Level Plaza (San Jose Convention Center).

Greg is one of the featured people on the Friday morning walk, but we plan to attend all four of them. It's probably the best place to meet to say hello, pick up a ribbon, and have a casual chat.

Panels

Greg will be on three different panels. By all means attend, ask questions, or just come up afterwards to say hi. Here's how the WorldCon schedule describes those panels:

Extrasolar, edited by Nick Gevers

[Anthology]

★★★☆☆ Mixed

(Hard SF) This anthology challenges writers to produce stories that explore extrasolar planets and incorporate the things we’ve learned about such things during the past couple of decades. (92,088 words; Time: 5h:06m)

Outstanding High Fantasy of 2016-2017

Here are 46 outstanding stories of high fantasy from 2016-2017 that were either finalists for major SF/F awards 🏆, included in "year's best" SF/F anthologies 📙, or recommended by prolific reviewers 👍 in short fiction (see Q&A). That's 46 out of 166 high fantasy stories from those two years, and out of 470 outstanding SF/F stories from 2016 and 2017.

For our purposes, we define "high fantasy" as a fantasy story that takes place in a secondary world. That is, something like Lord of the Rings, where Middle Earth is clearly not in the past or future of our world.

We've included portal fantasies, provided the destination is a secondary world.

Observations:

• 27 are free online (click to see yellow highlights).
• 15 (almost 1/3) are from Beneath Ceaseless Skies.
• The most prolific author in this list is Lois McMaster Bujold with 3 novellas.
• RSR recommended 26 of the stories and only recommended against 2.

July 2018 Ratings

5★ & 4★ Stories: 11; Time & Words: ⌚7h:34m 💬136.4K
Recommended By Stories: 32; Time & Words: ⌚15h 💬286.1K
Total Stories: 72; Time & Words: ⌚27h 💬492.9K
Read How to Use RSR on the sidebar or this link to use this post.

LibertyCon 31 Takeways

Walk with the Pros: Greg chats with Toni Weisskopf

A week ago, Greg and I attended LibertyCon 31 in Chattanooga, TN. We happened to be in town for our niece's wedding and we checked it out to see what a "conservative" SF/F convention was like.

Based on attending three panels and half the opening ceremonies on the first day, plus a Walk with the Pros on the third day, the attendees, panels, and operation of the con was comparable to small regional conventions like Norwescon in the Pacific Northwest. Baen Books had many authors present, and there seemed to be many authors with a military background (it was 5/5 in "The Resurgence of SF in YA Fiction" panel).

Planetary Anthology Roundtable panel with authors like
Arlan Andrews, Lou Antonelli, Jon Del Arroz, John C. Wright

Highlights include the opening ceremonies where Gray Rinehart sang a great flik based on the song "Brandy" to honor the con chairman and Charles E. Gannon read a funny speech, the Walk with the Pros where Greg had a good chat with Toni Weisskopf (publisher of Baen Books), and the Roundtable panels for shared world anthologies that gather a dozen or more authors for Q&A.

Special thanks to Brandy Spraker, chairman of LibertyCon, for inviting us to attend as temporary guests. The convention was sold out by the time we thought about attending (membership is capped at 750) but Brandy found a way to let us sample the first day when Greg inquired about one-day tickets.

June 2018 Ratings

5★ & 4★ Stories: 3; Time & Words: ⌚1h:06m 💬19.8K
Recommended By Stories: 14; Time & Words: ⌚5h:25m 💬97.6K
Total Stories: 30; Time & Words: ⌚11h 💬206.2K
Read How to Use RSR on the sidebar or this link to use this post.

Outstanding LGBT Science Fiction & Fantasy of 2017

June is Pride Month, and here are 45 outstanding stories with LGBT characters from 2017 that were either finalists for major SF/F awards 🏆, included in "year's best" SF/F anthologies 📙, or recommended by prolific reviewers 👍 in short fiction (see Q&A).

This list could be useful for making nominations for the 2018 Gaylactic Spectrum Awards for Best Short Fiction (published in 2010-2017). Anyone can nominate through June 30, 2018. Stories from 2017 are below. See Outstanding LGBT Science Fiction & Fantasy of 2015-2016 for earlier stories.

May 2018 Ratings

5★ & 4★ Stories: 10; Time & Words: ⌚6h:34m 💬118.5K
Recommended By Stories: 32; Time & Words: ⌚16h 💬300.6K
Total Stories: 72; Time & Words: ⌚31h 💬563.5K
Read How to Use RSR on the sidebar or this link to use this post.

2018 Hugo Voter Packet

As a finalist for the 2018 Hugo Award for Best Fanzine, we were invited to supply a copy of our work for the Hugo voter packet. Since Rocket Stack Rank published about 800 different articles last year (every review is its own article), that isn't very practical, so, as we did last year, we created an article (this post) to direct people to highlights from 2017.

For the benefit of people who don't see this page, we're including PDF, EPUB, and MOBI files in the official Hugo packet. Last year, we didn't think many people would use the packet (we thought they'd use the web page) so we simply included PDFs that were little better than screenshots of selected pages from the site. Some people complained that it looked shoddy, though, so this year we put a lot more time and effort into it, and we hope people are pleased by the result.

Sturgeon Award Finalists Versus Other Top Stories of 2017

All 11 Sturgeon Award finalists were in the top 10 in their respective categories in Rocket Stack Rank's Best SF/F of 2017 (228 stories out of 810 reviewed).

Novella

• The one Sturgeon finalist in this category is #1 out of 31 stories.
• It was tied with fellow Nebula & Hugo finalist "All Systems Red" prior to getting the Sturgeon recognition.

Novelette

• The four Sturgeon finalists in this category are in the top 10 out of 80 stories.
• Notable stories that missed the Sturgeon include "Wind Will Rove" (Nebula & Hugo finalist, NClarke year's best) and "Extracurricular Activities" (Hugo finalist, NClarke and RHorton year's best).

Short Story

• The six Sturgeon finalists in this category are in the top 10 out of 117 stories.
• Notable stories that missed the Sturgeon include "An Evening with Severyn Grimes" (GDozois, JStrahan, NClarke year's best) and "Carnival Nine" (Nebula & Hugo finalist, JStrahan year's best).

New Writers

• The three Sturgeon finalists whose authors were Year 1-eligible for the Campbell Award are in the top 4 out of 13 stories. There were no Sturgeon finalists among the five Year 2-eligible stories.
• Notable stories that missed the Sturgeon include "My English Name" (GDozois & JStrahan year's best) and "The Last Boat-Builder in Ballyvoloon" (GDozois & NClarke year's best).

April 2018 Ratings

5★ & 4★ Stories: 8; Time & Words: ⌚8h:15m 💬148.7K
Recommended By Stories: 20; Time & Words: ⌚12h 💬218.8K
Total Stories: 39; Time & Words: ⌚22h 💬398.9K
Read How to Use RSR on the sidebar or this link to use this post.

A Word for Authors

Clip arts

"I've never yet read a review of one of my own books that I couldn't have written much better myself."--Edward Abbey

For a variety of reasons, authors are generally told not to engage with reviewers. Reviews are for readers, not writers, and there is a natural adversarial relationship between authors and reviewers. Authors who publicly pressure reviewers risk alienating their own readers, or so some say.

Rocket Stack Rank is more than just a review site, though; it's also an index of short science fiction that many readers use to find stories--even readers who pay no attention to our reviews. Reviews are a matter of opinion, but the index is a matter of fact, and since its purpose is purely to guide readers to stories they might like, we and the authors have a common interest in making it as accurate as possible.

2018 Hugo Award Finalist

Thank you for nominating Rocket Stack Rank for the 2018 Hugo Award for Best Fanzine!

We had not expected a nomination this year, so we were greatly cheered at this vote of confidence. We will continue to work to make Rocket Stack Rank the most useful resource for readers and fans of short speculative fiction.

For new visitors, RSR consolidates recommendations from prolific SF/F short fiction reviewers (including RSR) in our monthly ratings, anthology ratings, and year-to-date ratings. For the best from past years, check out the News & Highlights section.

Read How to use RSR on the right sidebar or at this link for more details.

You can follow RSR on Twitter, Facebook, RSS, or e-mail.

Outstanding SF/F by People of Color 2015-2016

Update 3/29/18: Removed reviewer CPayseur at his request. Also see discussion of request by Hugo finalist Camestros Felapton.

In the spirit of Lightspeed Magazine's famous People of Color Destroy Science Fiction series, here are 92 stories by people of color that had a combined score of 2+ from RSR's 2015 & 2016 Best SF/F lists. The two lists together contain the 440 most-recommended stories out of 1,481 reviewed, so the 92 stories by people of color make up around 21% of the best of 2015-2016.

Readers asked us to make it easy for them to find good stories written by authors with diverse racial backgrounds, and that’s what this list is meant to accomplish (author identity plays no role in our ratings). Note that this is for fiction from 2015 and 2016 (RSR started September 2015); and we’ll prepare a similar list for 2017 once the finalists for various awards have been announced—probably in July or August.

Annotated 2017 File 770 List for Short Fiction

While we’re waiting for the Hugo administrators to produce the list of finalists, almost fifty "Filers" (commenters from File 770) shared their nominations, and we’ve used that to create lists for Best Novella, Best Novelette, and Best Short Story. In a couple of weeks, we can see how well they predicted the actual finalists.

In the 34 stories below, "votes" is the number of Filers who nominated that work, with the cut-off being three or more. Here are a few interesting findings from the 14 novellas, 10 novelettes, and 10 short stories:

March 2018 Ratings

5★ & 4★ Stories: 9; Time & Words: ⌚6h:01m 💬108.4K
Recommended By Stories: 41; Time & Words: ⌚18h 💬332.6K
Total Stories: 65; Time & Words: ⌚24h 💬437.2K
Read How to Use RSR on the sidebar or this link to use this post.

New Features: Flag, Rate, Group, Highlight Stories

To help readers navigate RSR's large lists of Hugo eligible stories, we've added features to let you flag stories to read ⚑ (and not read ✖), rate stories you've read ★, group and highlight stories by various criteria, and save your ratings to a URL that can be bookmarked and accessed on other devices.

You can quickly try it out on last month's ratings below by clicking here to skip a detailed walkthrough of the features that follow.

2017 Annotated Nebula Award Finalists

Update 4/17/18: Tagged Sturgeon Award finalists.
Update 4/02/18: Upgrade to dynamic table.
Update 2/26/18: Added link to free F&SF story "Dirty Old Town".

Here are the 2017 Nebula Award finalists for short fiction, sorted by score to highlight the stories that made it into the most "year's best" SF/F anthologies and were most recommended by prolific reviewers.

A story gets 2 points for each "year's best" SF/F anthology it's in (GDozois+2, RHorton+2, JStrahan+2, NClarke+2). Other factors that increase a story's score include honorable mentions from Locus Magazine reviewers Gardner Dozois (GDozois+1) and Rich Horton (RHorton+1) and "year's best" and honorable mentions from prolific short fiction reviewers Greg Hullender at Rocket Stack Rank (RSR+2, RSR+1), Sam Tomaino at SFRevu (SFRevu+2, SFRevu+1), and Jason McGregor at Featured Futures (JMcGregor+2, JMcGregor+1), all of whom reviewed 500+ SF/F stories for their magazines/blogs in 2017.